Evaluating the Effectiveness of Concept Distillation Prompts: A Comparative Analysis



This evaluation prompt assesses the effectiveness of different concept distillation prompts in generating concise and accurate summaries of complex topics.  You will be provided with three different prompts, each designed to distill the core concept of &#8216;Artificial Intelligence Safety&#8217;.  For each prompt, generate a 100-word summary.  After generating the summaries, compare and contrast them based on clarity, accuracy, completeness, and conciseness.  Finally, rank the three prompts based on their effectiveness in distilling the core concept.  Your final output should include:</p>
<p>* **Prompt 1 Summary:** (100-word summary generated using Prompt 1)<br />
* **Prompt 2 Summary:** (100-word summary generated using Prompt 2)<br />
* **Prompt 3 Summary:** (100-word summary generated using Prompt 3)<br />
* **Comparative Analysis:** A table comparing the three summaries across the four criteria (clarity, accuracy, completeness, conciseness) using a 1-5 rating scale (1=poor, 5=excellent).<br />
* **Prompt Ranking:** A ranked list of the three prompts (1=most effective, 3=least effective) with a brief justification for the ranking.</p>
<p>**Prompts to use for evaluation:**</p>
<p>**Prompt 1:**  &#8220;Distill the core concept of Artificial Intelligence Safety into a concise 100-word summary, focusing on the key challenges and potential risks.&#8221;</p>
<p>**Prompt 2:** &#8220;Imagine you are explaining Artificial Intelligence Safety to a 10-year-old.  Write a 100-word summary that captures the essence of the concept in simple terms.&#8221;</p>
<p>**Prompt 3:** &#8220;Summarize the central themes of Artificial Intelligence Safety in 100 words, highlighting the ethical, societal, and technical considerations.&#8221;</p>
<p>The evaluation should focus on the ability of each prompt to elicit a clear, accurate, and concise summary of the complex concept.